Tuesday, October 5, 2010
“It’s Money and Adventure and Fame. It’s the Thrill of a Lifetime.”
Monday, September 27, 2010
Sherlock: A New Sleuth for the 21st Century
The last series of Doctor Who saw writer/producer Steven Moffat
take over the reigns as head script editor and producer from Russell T Davies. People may ask who is Moffat and what has he done and was he good enough to take over for Davies. Moffat is a Scottish Television writer who has been writing for British Television including Press Gang featuring Julia Sawahla
, Chalk, Jekyll featuring James Nesbitt
, and Coupling
a British Comedy that took the U.S. by surprise. Given Moffat’s clear success, how would he do if he was given the chance to do Britain’s number one character of all time Sherlock Holmes? A few years back on a train ride to Cardiff, Moffat spoke with fellow Who alumnus Mark Gatiss about their love for Conan Doyle’s literary work Sherlock Holmes. Moffat and Gatiss found out both of them were interested in creating an updated version of Sherlock Holmes set in modern day times. After those discussions the two men set out to create their vision with the help of Moffat’s wife producer Sue Vertue. What they ended up doing was making a 60 minute pilot that cost around 800,000 pounds to produce to use as a vehicle to get a network to pick up the series. In July 2009, the BBC drama department announced plans for a further three 90-minute episodes, to be broadcast in 2010. The first episode, "A Study in Pink", was first broadcast in the United Kingdom on 25 July 2010 simultaneously on BBC One and BBC HD. The remaining episodes was broadcasted the following Sundays. I was able to catch the first two episodes from people who uploaded them onto the internet and was pretty impressed with what I saw, but decided to hold off my review of the series until I could get my hands on the 2 Disc BluRay set released in the U.K .
Sherlock is a British television series produced by Hartswood Films for BBC Wales, co-produced with WGBH Boston for its Masterpiece anthology series. Featuring Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock Holmes and Martin Freeman as Dr Watson
as well as Mark Gatiss as Mycroft Holmes
. The actors are well casted in their roles. Cumberbatch was the only guy Moffat considered for the role of Sherlock. It is easy to see why Cumberbatch is always one step ahead of the audience and comes across as a bit weird. I had no problem watching Cumberbatch as Holmes and I found myself half the time thinking Cumberbatch would be perfect as Doctor Who. Which in the end what makes Cumberbatch perfect for the role because I always envisioned Doctor Who what Sherlock Holmes would be like if he was traveling through space and time. Dr. Watson was a little bit harder for the producers to cast they even had Matt Smith audition for the role who in the end said his performance made him more suitable for the role of Sherlock Holmes. In the end the producers settled on Freeman. Freeman is a veteran actor who I have seen in many different films he usually plays similar characters to Dr. Watson. Freeman works so well off of Cumberbatch it feels as if you are watching the Odd Couple. The transition from the Victorian era of England to the modern day England also works out for the better. Sure some small changes were made to the characters, but they work out for the better for instance instead of smoking a pipe or using opium Holmes now uses nicotine patches “This, Watson, is a three-patch problem”. Holmes also has all of today’s technology at his fingertips and uses the technology to his advantage on many occasions during the series. As far as the stories go they were all great and really doing something I have not seen other versions for film or TV do returning to the core of Conan Doyle’s stories. Moffat says, "Conan Doyle's stories were never about frock coats and gas light; they're about brilliant detection, dreadful villains and blood-curdling crimes — and frankly, to hell with the crinoline. Other detectives have cases, Sherlock Holmes has adventures, and that's what matters". Gatiss criticizes recent television adaptations of the Conan Doyle stories as "too reverential and too slow", aiming to be as irreverent to the canon as the 1930s and '40s films starring Basil Rathbone. The Blu Ray features the first 3 episodes as well as the unaired pilot. The first episode is “A Study in Pink” written by Steven Moffat and directed by Paul McGuigan. The police investigate the deaths of a series of people who all appear to have committed suicide by taking a poisonous pill. They turn to their unofficial consultant, Sherlock Holmes, who deduces various elements pointing to a serial killer. Meanwhile, Holmes is introduced to John Watson, and the pair immediately move into a flat in Baker Street. This episode is a loose adaption of “A Study in Scarlet”. The second episode is “The Blind Baker” written by Stephen Thompson and directed by Euros Lyn. Sherlock is hired by an old friend to investigate a mysterious break-in at a bank in the City. The episode is a loose adaption of “The Dancing Men”. The third episode is “The Great Game” written by Mark Gatiss and directed by Paul McGuigan. Sherlock is commissioned by his brother Mycroft to investigate the suspicious death of a government employee who was working on a top-secret defence project; the Bruce-Partington Project. The Pilot after careful viewing is a shorter version of the first episode “A Study in Pink”. Story – A What is there to be said, but after three episodes I am addicted. The settings, acting, and more just gel together and it is brilliant. I would love to go into more detail, but with a U.S. premiere date on PBS soon there is no need to give any spoilers. I was looking for a show to take the place of Ashes to Ashes when it went off the air. I think I found that show. Video Quality – A The Blu Ray keeps the 1080i/16:9 high definition formats that were used when the BBC first aired this on BBCHD. None of the video suffers from any scratches, dirt, or debris. The images are clear and simply breathtaking it feels as if I can jump into the screen and join their adventure with them. This release is a prime example of how much better a movie and TV can look at home with the right setup than seeing it in the theaters. Extras – A I am not a big guy for extras for most films or TV shows so I don’t ask for much. Included on this release is a commentary for episode 1featuring Gatiss, Moffat, and Vertue, a commentary for episode 3 featuring Cumberbatch, Freeman, and Gatiss, the pilot episode, and Unlocking Sherlock – The making of. A person cannot ask for much more than that out of any release. Overall – A This a great series definitely worthy of taking the time out of your schedule to watch. The Blu Ray does the series justice and the way I suggest to view it. Sherlock may be Moffat’s best series to date and gives the works of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle the respect they deserve. Sherlock will be airing on PBS stations across the U.S. 24 October 2010. A DVD and Blu Ray are scheduled to be released in the United States on 9 November 2010.Friday, August 20, 2010
Max Headroom 20 Minutes Into the Future
Theora Jones- Michelle Ryan Murray- Jeffrey TamborThursday, August 5, 2010
The Professionals
Two of the most liked British shows of all time are now in the works to get their own theatrical movie I looked at one of those in my last review The Sweeney. Today I am going to look at the other show The Professionals CI5. The Professionals was created by recently awarded O.B.E Brian Clemens best remembered in the U.S. for as the creator the Avengers and featured Lewis Collins as Bodie
, Martin Shaw as Doyle
, and Gordon Jackson as Cowley
. The show had a simple premise CI5 (Criminal Intelligence 5) is a law enforcement department, instructed by the Home Secretary to use any means, which deals with crimes of a serious nature that go beyond the capacity of the police, but are not tasks for the secret service or military. It was ITV's response for the Sweeney and very simular to Starsky and Hutch. The episode I am looking at today is the story the Klansmen which is the one episode that has been banned from being shown on tv since it originally aired back in 1977. While the episode features no noticable guest stars from what I can see however beyond that factor it is one of the best episodes to give an explanation of the series and what sets it apart from other shows. For the benefit of readers who have not seen the episode, I have given a detailed synopsis of the story below. PLEASE NOTE I have pointed out various aspects of the script – not because I agree with them, but simply to illustrate exactly why LWT felt uncomfortable with it. The Klansmen The story opens with a middle-aged black couple, the Culvers, having their furniture thrown into the street by two white thugs intent on evicting them. Mrs Culver is sobbing and her husband is helpless. Despite the fact that a crowd has gathered to watch, nobody is willing to come to his aid. However a smart Mercedes suddenly draws up and a young black man steps out. We later discover he is a lawyer by the name of Zadie (played by Trevor Thomas. He orders the thugs to return all the furniture back into the house and pay for any breakages. One of the thugs, Dinny (Tony Booth), turns on Zadie: "You wanna mix it with me, nigger?!". Zadie, cool and unflinching, replies that he has obtained a court order to prevent the eviction and that as 'nigger' is simply a deformation of 'negro', the term does not offend him. This retort winds Dinny up even more and he threatens to thump Zadie - who in turn happily invites the thug to take a swing: after all there are plenty of witnesses! Dinny and his mate, Merv, decide they are beaten and start to replace the furniture. Zadie reassures the Culvers and then drives off. However one of the spectators, Hulton (Edward Judd), approaches Dinny and invites him to join his "Empire Society", a small local establishment devoted to the ousting of coloureds. Later Dinny phones his boss, Mr Miller, to explain what happened at the Culver's house. Miller tells Dinny and Merv to join the Empire Society, much to Dinny's surprise. That evening Hulton and his mob, dressed intraditional Ku Klux Klan white robes and hoods, pay a visit on Zadie, throwing a brick through a window and erecting a huge wooden burning cross in his front garden. Zadie runs outside to challenge the men but there are too many of them and he comes under physical attack. Zadie's white wife Helen (played by Sheila Ruskin) witnesses the scene and screams abuse at the men as they run away. Opening Credits Roll Next day the incident comes to the attention of Cowley and, as a man who has seen and been appalled by much racial hatred in his time, decides to send Bodie and Doyle in to investigate. Bodie thinks this is a waste of CI5 resources: after all "all they did was plant a cross in a spade's garden". Cowley reacts furiously to this remark, warning Bodie not to use that term again, then sends the lads on their way. They go to interview Zadie and Bodie is plainly aghast when he sees that his wife is white. Zadie notices this but Bodie clumsily tries to cover up his feelings. However shortly after leaving Zadie's home, Bodie expresses to Doyle his resentfulness at the fact that a "spade" should own a nice, large house and drive a brand new Mercedes. Doyle, like Cowley, rebukes Bodie for making such remarks. The lads then go on into the area of the town where the tenants live and try to make further investigations. At the same time a young black man by the name of Arty has discovered an accounts book with some information in it that he thinks Zadie should be made aware of. However before he can speak to Zadie, he is cornered by the hooded Klansmen and pushed off a rooftop, falling to his death. The lads arrive on the scene and Bodie tries to investigate the death by questioning some black youths. However they don't take kindly to this and when Bodie threatens to take one of them, Tommy, in for interrogation, they stab him and leave him for dead. Fortunately Bodie is able to radio for help. On the way to hospital in an ambulance Doyle wants to know who was responsible and Bodie manages to gasp "Tell Cowley a spade did this - a dirty black spade". On arriving at hospital, Bodie has lost so much blood that he is now in a very demented state and goes beserk when he sees that the doctor who will be treating him is black. "Get off me, you black bastard!". The doctor manages to administer an injection which subdues Bodie into sleep. In the meantime Hulton has called a meeting of the Empire Society to express his fury about Arty's murder: although he doesn't completely disapprove of the action, he fears that to take such extreme measures might make the white population turn against the Society. He demands to know which members of the group were responsible for the death but nobody owns up. The second item on the meeting's agenda is Zadie and a decision to step up further the crusade against him: "Let's go scare the arse of that flash nigger lawyer!". Doyle, suspecting there might be another attack on Zadie, is watching in the bushes when Hulton's men (again, dressed in the familiar white Klansmen attire) arrive. Zadie, inside the house, hears the doorbell and opens the door to be greeted with a tin of white paint thrown over him: "Now you're as white as that wife of yours!" bellows the disguised Hulton. On hearing the commotion, Mrs Zadie runs to her husband's side only to be drenched in paint herself - but this time it is black: ".... and you're the same colour as him!" Hulton roars before the whole gang turn and run off. Doyle, seeing that the Zadies are unharmed, follow Hulton's gang as they retreat to the safety of the Empire Society building. On seeing the name of the club, Doyle quickly realises what is going on and informs Cowley. In the meantime Bodie remains in a poor state at the hospital and his demented outbursts continue. They are overheard by a young black nurse and she is visibly upset but nevertheless continues to attend to his wounds. Doyle suggests he goes undercover and joins the Empire Society. By staging a racially-motivated fight with black CI5 operative Jax in front of Hulton, his invitation to join the society is soon forthcoming. At yet another meeting that night, he not only plays along with the groups' attitudes but actively encourages them to take much more extreme measures - "I've got a shotgun in my car!". Hulton is appalled by this and rebukes Doyle, explaining that is is not the group's intention to murder anybody. "What about the guy on the roof, though?" Doyle excitedly points out. The group go out on one of their hooded jaunts and we see Dinny telephoning somebody: "There's a guy here with a shotgun.... should make a nice connection!". Shortly afterwards a middle-aged black man is gunned down by a Klansman. In the meantime the rest of the group are daubing racist slogans on the walls and garages of several tenants' houses. The dead man was, in fact, Zadie's business partner, Carter, and Cowley is now very worried. In the meantime Doyle visits the Empire's office and, on the pretence that he has been summoned by Hulton, searches the various filing cabinets and desks. But Hulton himself turns up unexpectedly with Dinny and Merv and the three of them, catching Doyle rifling the office, beat him senseless - his injuries are appalling but he remains conscious. The three interrogate him and he convinces them that he is working as a freelance reporter, trying to find out more about the Society so he can publish an article in a local black newspaper. Dinny and Merv then pile Doyle into their car and dump him at a nearby water-tower - ironically the same place at which Bodie was knifed. Doyle lapses into unconciousness. A little while later the young kid Tommy turns up at the tower to play with his tennis ball and racquet. He discovers Doyle and administers food and water. Doyle manages to struggle to his feet and slowly start to recover, but his bruising is horrifying! Tommy tells Doyle about Bodie being knifed and Doyle explains that he is after the men who have been tormenting and murdering the blacks in the area. Tommy explains that he thinks Arty might have been murdered because of a robbery he pulled at the offices of Mr Miller, the property owner. It seems that Arty had discovered the account book contained some figures in it that would incriminate Miller. Yet witnesses had described seeing Klansmen running away fom the rooftop, so they would be Hulton's men, not Miller's. Doyle happens to find Jax and asks to borrow his gun. Jax, shocked by Doyle's condition, contacts Cowley and arranges for him to meet Doyle at Miller's offices. Although still in a bad shape, Doyle arrives at the building before Cowley and discovers Dinny and Merv - who are two of Miller's employees, of course. He manages to overpower and tie them up - with Tommy as 'back-up'! A quick search of the offices reveals that the reason Miller wants the tenants evicted is so that he can sell the land for redevelopment and make a quick fortune. Interrogation of Dinny throws up a more pressing problem, though. It seems that Miller has arranged for some other men to murder Zadie that evening. Miller thinks that with Zadie out of the way, he will be able to carry out his evictions. Leaving Tommy with Jax's gun, Doyle rushes off, asking the youngster to explain things to Cowley when he arrives. Tommy: "This Mr Cowley - is he white or black?", Doyle: "Hmmm.... I never thought to ask!" At around the same time Zadie receives a phone call from the tenant Mr Culver saying that some men have come back to his house to try to throw him out again. Zadie sees this as an ideal opportunity to land Miller in court and, grabbing various legal documents, heads for Culver's house. However when he arrives he discovers the house is intact and that men are actually Klan members waiting to kill him: Culver had been forced into making the telephone call. Doyle arrives and is forced to shoot the men when he sees Zadie is just about to be killed. Zadie, grateful to Doyle, expresses his distaste for the men: "White trash!". However removing the hood of one of the men reveals that he is actually black!?! By now Cowley has arrived at Miller's office and discovers young Tommy guarding the bound Dinny and Merv. Cowley gets Dinny to phone Miller to ask him to come to the office. Dinny, a "dyed-in-the-wool black-hater" has never actually met Miller, merely spoken to him on the telephone. So he is absolutely shocked to discover that when Miller arrives, he himself is black! It would appear that Miller had decided run his tenants out of town by using Hulton's Empire Society as a cover - with Miller's men dressed in Klan robes, they would naturally appear to be associated with Hulton! It was Miller's men, not Hulton's, who had murdered Arty and Carter and had just tried to kill Zadie. By now Bodie has recovered well and we see him thanking the doctor who has just saved his life. He also apologises for his behaviour. But to top that, Doyle is amazed to see his partner strolling off hand-in-hand with the young black nurse who treated him. A bit envious of this, Doyle declares to Jax: "Right, now we start our campaign.... to get rid of some of these damned whites!" It is easy to see why they never showed this episode despite being one of the strongest episodes of the series it is the most controversial. They show just how far they are willing to go with violence, words, and more without stopping. While Bodie is never portrayed this way again in the series because the producers thought it was bad for the characters image. One bizarre aspect of the whole situation is that prior to filming, all episode scripts were sent to LWT for 'vetting'. At this stage they could request changes to the scripts, if they felt these were necessary. Amazingly 'Klansmen' was given the 'OK', apparently with no change requests at all. So Mark 1 naturally went on to actually film it. It was only AFTER filming had completed and Mark 1 had wrapped up the first season that LWT suddenly decided that the episode was unacceptable. Brian Clemens has said that had LWT notified him in time, he would have happily adjusted the script to appease them. But I suspect the fact that Mark 1 had all "gone home" and, consequently, various members of the cast and crew were not available, then re-shooting was not possible. To be fair, I must add that Lew Collins himself was not very happy with the episode and, judging by his remarks in the Channel 4 documentary, was probably relieved when it got pulled! However despite the controversial episode about the content in this episode. This is what The Professionals show was all about. The Professionals on more than one occassion was willing to go where The Sweeney was not willing to even touch which is amazing considering the amount of violence on The Sweeney. Over the top acting, unbelievable action sequences, and great stories with alot of one liners in it "You may be bigger than me, Bodie, but you're not tougher.... at least not when I've got this gun!" Cowley "It's time to kick ass and chew bubble-gum." Bodie It is what sets this show apart from others and why 30 years after the fact it is still remembered today. The show is also unintentionally funny because of the onscreen chemistry of Bodie and Doyle partnership can leave different views of a what people may think of them just ask the people of Comic Strip Presents. The Bullshitters: Roll Out The Gunbarrel was a spoof of The Professionals, first broadcast in 1984 on Channel 4. Although it was made by many people behind The Comic Strip, it did not feature the Comic Strip logo and is not considered by some to be part of the series. However, it was included in the Comic Strip DVD box set (2005), and its lead characters Bonehead and Foyle reappeared in a later Comic Strip episode, Detectives on the Edge of a Nervous Breakdown. The Bullshitters When Commander Jackson (Robbie Coltrane), head of DI5, hears that his daughter Janie has been kidnapped and held for ransom, he has to call in ex-agents Bonehead (Keith Allen) and Foyle (Peter Richardson) to save her. Since being kicked out of DI5, Bonehead works at a TV Tough Guys School, teaching others the "rules" of being a TV tough guy (such as not locking your car because you need to get straight back into it), and Foyle is now an actor on stage. Jackson blackmails the two into working together. It's time for Bonehead and Foyle - the flashiest, fastest and most under-dressed detectives to be kicked out of DI5 to get back to work. With a Magnum in one hand and a bus pass in the other, the Bullshitters set out to track down the criminals and get some good close-ups. However, as every good TV cop knows, not all is as it seems, especially Bonehead and Foyle's relationship with each other - is there a reason they wear so little clothing around each other? Quite honestly you know you did something great when they are making fun of your show. DVD Box Set Overall D Now while the content itself is great the source material they used for the transfer is terrible and the lack of special features makes it worse. This is not the worst i have seen for DVD release but this is up their in the top fiveworst releases I have laid my eyes upon and can safely only get this set if your a true fan of the series. While The Professionals is not for everybody it is very easy to fall in love with it like I have and definately good for few unintentional laughs. I highly recommend the series just not the DVD release. 
Sunday, July 25, 2010
The Sweeney
Today I am taking a look at The Sweeney a British Television police show that forever changed the way of how cop shows were made in the U.K. for the better or worse. The Sweeney stars John Thaw
as Jack Regan, Dennis Waterman as George Carter, and Garfield Morgan
as DCI Frank Haskins. The origins of this show actually dates back to another show the highly successful ITV Armchair Theatre which ran one off episodes that tyically lasted about 110 minutes and featured stories in a wide variety of settings and eras. The interesting thing about the Armchair Theatre sometimes public response to certain episodes could lead to individual episodes getting picked up for their own series for instance A Magnum for Schieder led to Callan and Regan led to The Sweeney. The Sweeney was created by Ian Kennedy Martin who has contributed to a lot of other police dramas and the brother of better known writer Troy Kennedy Martin remembered mostly today for writing the classic Italian Job film and Edge of Darkness Tv Series. Ian was forced off the show early on by producer Ted Childs who should be given a lot of credit of how the series direction went and was filmed. Lets just say Ian wanted less action and more dialougue and Ted disagreed with this. What we ended up getting in the end was a cop show shot entirely on film, on location, and heavy on the action sequences. Which gave the U.K. something they have never seen before a degree of realism never seen in a cop show before raw and intense. The Sweeney ended up being the first really modern police-based series on British television. Previously, most dramas featuring the police had shied away from showing 'coppers' as fallible human beings. The police in The Sweeney were a million miles away from those of the BBC's cosy world of Dixon of Dock Green, or even from the BBC's slightly more realistic Z Cars. They were brutal and violent in dealing with London's hardened criminals, and prone to cutting corners and bending laws. The series showed a somewhat more realistic side of the police which often had a disregard for authority, rules and the 'system', as long it got the job done. Until The Sweeney this had been a subject largely whitewashed by British television. It was a fast-paced edge-of-your-seat action series, depicting the Squad's relentless battle against armed robbery; but it nevertheless included a substantial degree of humour. For the time, it had a high degree of graphic on-screen violence and the episodes had a high number of on-screen deaths. As a result of this it led to alot of big name actors, writers, and directors wanting to get in on the project as well as two feature films which allowed the people to do what little they were not able to get away with on television which was not much. The series focuses on veteran police inspector Jack Regan and his new partner George Carter while they go out and investigate crimes and try to solve the mystery anyway they can all under the supervision of DCI Frank Haskins who play a very small role in the majority of the episodes. Sometimes the inspectors save the day, sometimes they get crapped on and fail, and sometimes nothing can go their way. It is absolutely the main reasons I love this series because they do mess up and move on. In one episode two rival squads get setup against each other in an ambush and the villain gets away as a small example of what can happen. Today I am looking at the episode Hit and Run guest starring Patrick Troughton and Michael Sheard in the same episode. To be honest with the phrase bad things happen when the Doctor comes can really apply to this particular episode. This was the first episode written by Roger Marshall for the series who ended up writing 8 episodes for the series and is considered to be the one writer who worked with actor John Thaw the most throughout his years. Hit and Run starts off with a lady who is trying to get out of a crime syndicate and is warned by her contact you just can't leave they will silence you. Opening Credits role and we start off with George Carter returning home from a long day at work whose wife is now getting mad at him because of the hours and leaves him to go to work. A few moments later we run into Patrick Troughton who is a used car dealer and the man from the intro saying the woman is quitting. Troughton decides to call up a guy to put up a hit on the female. Flash Foward a few scenes Carter's wife is leaving the school and is given a jacket by the lady from the opening sequence since she forget hers and she works with her. A few moments later on the way home Carter's wife is involved in a hit and run accident by mistake and dies. In real life the actress wanted more money to stay on the show. Quite honestly in the end this decision led to Carter being a much more free character throughout the rest of the series. I will not give away the rest, but this is one of the best episodes of the series because it falls into one of the categories mentioned above. Are there some bad episodes in the bunch sure, but it is far outweighed by the number of outstanding episodes. Some of the episodes I do suggest include from Series 1 the Ringer, Queen's Pawn, Jigsaw, and Abduction Series 2 Hit and Run Series 4 Hearts and Mind with Morecambe and Wise as themselves in what has to be the funniest car chase of the series and Jack or Knave the series finale. Video Quality - A There is very little artifacting and they have been cleaned up beautifully Network did suprisingly did a nice job. Special Features - A When it comes to series like these I don't ask for much, but they do deliver on a very nice scale with veteran actors like Tony Selby doing the intro to his ep, wirters, directors, actors' families like Morecombe and Wise's family looking back and stunt men on the project doing interviews with alot of audio commentaries thoughout and nice thing is they give you a choice 5.1 and mono the way they were filmed. Overall - A What else could I give a release handled this nicely not much. Be on the lookout for veteran actors Patrick Troughton, Michael Sheard, Warren mitchel, Morecombe and Wise, Roy Kinnear, Richard Griffiths, Brian Glover, Denholm Elliott, Brian Blessed, and Lynda Bellingham. The Sweeney is a great series and hard to describe without seeing it. It is very easy to see why shows like Life On Mars borrowed heavily on this series because Gene Hunt could easily be a take off of Jack Regan and Sam Tyler could be the George Carter that wants to stand up against Jack Regan on a few occasions because of actions. This show is a piece of television history that still stands up well today and is definately worth watching at least once.

Sunday, June 27, 2010
Yojimbo/Sanjuro Blu-Ray Boxset from Criterion vs DVD Boxset

Yojimbo/Sanjuro BluRay Set Vs. Yojimbo/Sanjuro DVD Set from Criterion
With the coming of BluRay discs one question always is on the back of people's mind is it worth double, triple, or quadruple dipping on movies that you have already bought? To answer that question is really hard, but should come down to some factors. 1. How much do you love the film? Is it one of your all time favorites or is it on the bottom of the list? 2. How good was the transfer before? If it was one of the first releases on DVD the transfer could look terrible. 3. What type of film it is? Certain types of films like Action, Sci-Fi, Horror, and Fantasy it can really make a differance in between a BluRay and DVD. Today I'm looking at Yojimbo/Sanjuro BluRay Boxset vs Criterion's last DVD release for them. Yojimbo falls into category factor 1 and 3, Im not worried about the transfer being of bad quality considering Criterion did the release before. To understand the Criterion Collection it is owned by Janus Films who currently sells World cinema, mainstream cinema classics, and critically-successful “obscure” movies. Using the best available source materials, the company produces technologically improved versions, thus, The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928), M (1931), and the Children of Paradise (1945) discs contain film-cleaning and film-restoration demonstrations, comparing the restored and un-restored images; not every film company approved of the comparison exercise — the Toho Company took exception to the restoration demonstration in Criterion's first DVD release of Seven Samurai (1954); the re-issued version does not contain it. So you get the best when it comes to this companies transfers. Both of these films being looked at today are being directed by Akira Kurosawa
considered by many including myself the greatest director in film history and starring Toshiro Mifune
easily the greatest actor to grace the Japanese Cinema. Another actor to grace these productions is Takashi Shimura
another regular who Kurosawa uses often and has a great onscreen chemistry with Mifune.Yojimbo/Sanjuro
On the Box
Thanks to perhaps the most indelible character in Akira Kurosawa’s oeuvre, Yojimbo surpassed even Seven Samurai in popularity when it was released. The masterless samurai Sanjuro, who slyly manipulates two warring clans to his own advantage in a small, dusty village, was so entertainingly embodied by the brilliant Toshiro Mifune that it was only a matter of time before he returned in a sequel. Made just one year later, Sanjuro matches Yojimbo’s storytelling dexterity yet adds layers of world-weary pragmatism that brings the two films to a thrilling and unforgettable conclusion. Criterion is proud to present these Kurosawa masterworks in new, high-definition digital transfers and Blu-ray editions.
Restored high-definition digital transfers (with uncompressed monaural soundtracks on the Blu-ray editions)
Optional Dolby Digital 3.0 soundtracks, preserving the original Perspecta simulated sound effects (DTS-HD Master Audio on the Blu-ray edition)
Audio commentaries by Kurosawa scholar Stephen Prince
Documentaries on the making of Yojimbo and Sanjuro, created as part of the Toho Masterworks series Akira Kurosawa: It Is Wonderful to Create
Theatrical teasers and trailers
Stills galleries of behind-the-scenes photos
New and improved English subtitle translation
PLUS: Booklets featuring essays by film writers Alexander Sesonske and Michael Sragow and comments from Kurosawa and members of his cast and crew
Yojimbo

On the Box
To rid a terror-stricken village of corruption, wily masterless samurai Sanjuro (Toshiro Mifune) turns a range war between two evil clans to his own advantage in Akira Kurosawa’s visually stunning and darkly comic Yojimbo.
Story - A+
Yojimbo is one of the most copied films in the history of film even still to this day it is being rewritten and remade. Yojimbo is almost 50 years old now since it was originally released and is as brilliant today as it was when it was released very few films can say it withstood the test of time like this film and translates into just about any culture. Alot of this is to due with the simple factor Kurosawa wrote the story in such a way that any culture could relate to it by the settings characters, and storyline. Which is why All Movie Guide gives it a 5 out of 5 and it finishes #139 on the top250 films on IMDB and #15 out on the foriegn film list after all these years including two other Kurosawa film finishing ahead of it Rashoman and the Seven Samurai. Some of the films it has been remade as is Django, A Fistful of Dollars, Last Man Standing, the Zatoichi 2003 remake, and El Mariachi.
Video Quality - A BluRay

Criterion's new Blu-ray edition of Yojimbo is a direct upgrade of the 2007 DVD release. The film is now offered in stunning 1080p high-definition. Contrast is very good, with deep, detailed blacks and overall image texture is nicely refined. Very light grain remains, preserving the proper film-like experience. Thanks to the restoration work, age-related issues are minimal. Slight variation in contrast and detail is visible from scene to scene, but other than the occasional missing frame (presumably damaged, also seen on the DVD), the visual presentation is consistently excellent. And it is a vast improvement when comparing the 99 release by criterion of this film I am now amazed Criterion ever had their name on that release

Special Features - B
This is the same special features as on the DVD release except for an addition of the DTS HD Master Audio. I can't complain much for an almost fifty year old film it has alot with it. However probably most likely to do with Toho it is missing one feature I love from almost every Criterion release the restoration process special feature comparing it to the original and in this case I would of loved to have seen a DVD to BluRay transfer comparrison for prints. I was left speechless by the one Warner made when they released Wizard of Oz onto BluRay.
Sanjuro

On the Box
In Kurosawa’s sly companion piece to Yojimbo, jaded samurai Sanjuro helps an idealistic group of young warriors weed out their clan’s evil influences, and in the process turns their image of a “proper” samurai on its ear.
Story - B
While not quite as good as Yojimbo and originally intended to be a different film altogether pressure from Toho after the success of Yojimbo forced Kurosawa to rewrite the script and gear it to be a sequal for Yojimbo. Which in the end takes away from the film despite that fact it is still a good film it doesn't quite seem like this story is meant for a sequal for Yojimbo or that character Sanjuro neccessarily fits in completely. If this was made by almost anybody else, but Kurosawa it might of gotten a higher rating. AMG gives it 3.5 out of 5 Stars I think rightfully so and it recieves an 8.0 out of 10 on IMDB.
Video Quality - B

Sanjuro arrives on Blu-ray in an excellent 2.35.1 AVC encoded 1080p anamorphic widescreen transfer. The black and white image is incredibly crisp and shows far more detail than was present on the previous standard definition releases that Criterion has released over the years. Clarity is striking while contrast looks to be set properly. Fine detail and texture is always strong, you'll really notice it in the facial close ups where you can make out every little hair and all of the grit on the cast members faces. There aren't any problems with mpeg compression artifacts or edge enhancement and while a welcome and natural coat of grain is evident throughout, there are only the mildest instances of print damage to note. There are a few scenes that look softer than others and there are some instances where you might notice a bit of flickering but Kurosawa fans can rest assured that this is a big step up from the standard definition releases and a completely worthwhile upgrade in the visuals department.

Special Features - B
This is the same special features as on the DVD release except for an addition of the DTS HD Master Audio. I can't complain much for an almost fifty year old film it has alot with it. However probably most likely to do with Toho it is missing one feature I love from almost every Criterion release the restoration process special feature comparing it to the original and in this case I would of loved to have seen a DVD to BluRay transfer comparison for prints.
Box Set
Overall B+
As I said in a post on facebook don't buy this set if all your looking for is more special features than the 2007 release because you will be dissapointed. However if your looking for the best transfer to date with uncompressed video and audio quality this release is for you. Which is why I chose to buy this set again. Again I urge people to consider the factors i listed above before double or triple dipping.
Up next I am going to look at a British TV series called the Sweeney a cop show from the seventies that changed the way cop shows were made and looked at featuring the late John Thaw and singer/actor Dennis Waterman.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
